Coconut Milk Yogurt Attempt #1

by HEAB on October 7, 2010

Hello my almond butter loving friends. If you're new to HEAB, you may like to subscribe to my RSS feed or receive my posts via email. Thanks for reading!

Several of you sent me The Spunky Coconut’s Dairy Free Yogurt recipe, and so I decided to give it a try last night…with a few HEABifications.

First I brought 6 cups of HEABified coconut milk (perhaps mistake #1) along with 1 TBSP of honey (the yogurt cultures need some sugar to feed on) to a simmer on the stove-top. I didn’t have any gelatin, and so I subbed 1.5 TBSP of tapioca starch (definitely mistake #2).

I then removed my coconut milk + honey + tapioca starch from the heat, poured it in a stainless steel bowl and placed it in a sink of cold water, whisking away until the temperature dropped to 92℉ and then added 1 container of Oikos chocolate Greek yogurt as my starter culture. To keep it dairy free, you could add some store bought coconut milk yogurt, starter grains, or probiotic capsules, but I happen to have some Oikos on hand.

IMG_6172.JPG IMG_6171.JPG

I then poured my yogurt into my yogurt maker (thanks again Carolyn) and allowed it to incubate for 12 hours. Oops…was aiming for 10 hours, but slept a little longer than planned.


I was so excited to check on my yogurt this morning, but I wouldn’t really call it yogurt per say…it was more like cultured coconut milk. It tasted great – love that yogurt tang, but it was not thick at all. However, I’m hoping that after it chills in the fridge for a while it will thicken up a bit.


I think using coconut milk straight from the can rather than my HEABified version would have worked better, and I probably should have used at least a 1/4 cup tapioca starch rather than just 1.5 TBSP. Oh well, at least it tastes good, and I do love a good kitchen experiment.

Until I get the yogurt right, I’ll just keep snacking on my 2-ingredient fudge


Shameless self-promotion 😉